Selectors to blame for India loss, writes Ian Chappell

Selectors' failure to address issues like an ageing batting line-up, a declining off-spinner and substandard fielding in the five-day game has finally knocked India off the top spot in Tests

Selectors to blame for India loss, writes Ian Chappell

Selectors' failure to address issues like an ageing batting line-up, a declining off-spinner and substandard fielding in the five-day game has finally knocked India off the top spot in Tests

India's performance against England has been abysmal but things could get worse before they get better.
India's disastrous tour of England has been awhile in the making. The selectors' failure to address issues like an ageing batting line-up, a declining off-spinner and substandard fielding in the five-day game, has finally come home to roost.

VVS Laxman is bowled by James Anderson during the second
Test against England at Trent Bridge. PIC/getty images

The shrewdness of MS Dhoni's captaincy, the potency of Virender Sehwag's stroke play and Zaheer Khan's bowling, have all done a better job than Spackle in covering up the Indian cracks. Like firemen on their sliding pole, the descent for India will be much quicker than their steady climb up the rankings.u00a0

In all likelihood, India will be ranked number three by the time they tour Australia. Following three heavy losses to England in the last Ashes series, Australia was assumed to be easy pickings for India.

I wouldn't be so sure. With all Australia's problems and there are many, with two reviews into poor performance running concurrently, they do have fast bowling potential. If they get the bulk of their young fast bowlers fit for selection, Australia should field a decent pace attack.u00a0u00a0If they do, the Indian selectors, who have been negligent in their duty, could face their worst nightmare.

Talent is overlooked
The selectors have been reluctant to show faith in some of the talented young Indian batsmen. Now they have to choose a team for Australia where there are serious questions about the ability of some to play short-pitched bowling. Further muddying the pool, India's better batsmen are now a liability in the field.

Most Australian pace bowlers grow up certain of one thing; they know how to bang the ball in short. Whether they do it wisely is often another question but judging by the performance of Suresh Raina, Abhinav Mukund and Yuvraj Singh in England, quantity will suffice if quality is in short supply.

The Indian selectors then have the added concern of the bowlers. In addition to batting and fielding weaknesses, the bowling attack is in tatters. The Australians can struggle against good spin bowling. There have already been glimpses of this in Sri Lanka, although the Test batsmen are better equipped than those whose demise in the T20 series was abject.

In the days when India didn't have much pace bowling they were still able to hold their heads high in Australia, thanks to quality spinners. In 1967-68 and then 1977-78 India made Australia fight hard for every advantage through the skill of spinners like Erapalli Prasanna, Bhagwath Chandrasekhar and Bishan Bedi.

Those times are a distant memory. Harbhajan Singh has long been a better defensive bowler than an attacking weapon. And while Amit Mishra is a steady leg-spinner, who has some value in Australia, he needs the faster bowlers taking early wickets to be effective.

If, India can get Zaheer fit and Ishant Sharma back to the form he displayed on his last tour of Australia then they, plus Mishra and another good spinner, could be India's best balanced attack. The selectors have to decide whether Harbhajan is worth the gamble and if they do, then hope Dhoni can cajole/berate his off-spinner into a return to his more attacking ways.

The biggest issue facing the Indian selectors is finding a batting line-up that can score enough runs in Australia to give the bowlers a chance. Of the experienced batsmen Sehwag is the best equipped to mount a counter-attack that will set the Australians back on their heels. However, it's too much to expect Sehwag to play a lone hand so Sachin Tendulkar may be forced to play a more pro-active role in this ploy.u00a0
u00a0u00a0
Of the younger batsmen, Rohit Sharma is the most talented and also copes best with the short-pitched delivery. He should've been in the Test side awhile back. It would be asking a lot of him to take on an aggressor's role in his first Test series and in a hostile environment.

Then comes the job of drastically improving the fielding. It's crucial to catch well and field athletically on the big grounds in Australia. With ageing batsmen and poor fielding bowlers, this will be a difficult selection jigsaw
puzzle.

The selectors have failed to confront the tough issues and now face a "damned if you do and damned if you don't" situation. If India does slide quickly down the rankings, weaknesses off, as well as on the field, will have played their part.